Tipping, as a compensation scheme, is great for everyone.
Restaurant customers like tipping because it puts them in the driver’s seat. As a diner, you control your experience, using the power of your tip to make sure your server works hard for you.
Restaurant servers like tipping because it means their talent is rewarded. As a great server, you get paid more than your peers, because you are a better worker.
Restaurant owners like tipping because it means they don’t have to pay for managers to closely supervise their servers. With customers using tips to enforce good service, owners can be confident that servers will do their best work.
There’s only one problem: none of this is actually true. I know because I ran the experiment myself.
For over eight years, I was the owner and operator of San Diego’s farm-to-table restaurant The Linkery, until we closed it this summer to move to San Francisco. At first, we ran the Linkery like every other restaurant in America, letting tips provide compensation and motivation for our team. In our second year, however, we tired of the tip system, and we eliminated tipping from our restaurant. We instead applied a straight 18% service charge to all dining-in checks, and refused to accept any further payment. We became the first and, for years, the only table-service restaurant in America where you couldn’t pay more money than the amount we charged you.
You can guess what happened. Our service improved, our revenue went up, and both our business and our employees made more money. Here’s why:
- Researchers have found (pdf) that customers don’t actually vary their tips much according to service. Instead they tip mostly the same every time, according to their personal habits.
- Tipped servers, in turn, learn that service quality isn’t particularly important to their revenue. Instead they are rewarded for maximizing the number of guests they serve, even though that degrades service quality.
- Furthermore, servers in tipping environments learn to profile guests (pdf), and attend mainly to those who fit the stereotypes of good tippers. This may increase the server’s earnings, while creating negative experiences for the many restaurant customers who are women, ethnic minorities, elderly or from foreign countries.
- On the occasions when a server is punished for poor service by a customer withholding a standard tip, the server can keep that information to himself. While the customer thinks she is sending a message, that message never makes it to a manager, and the problem is never addressed.
You can see that tipping promotes and facilitates bad service. It gives servers the choice between doing their best work and making the most money. While most servers choose to do their best work, making them choose one or the other is bad business.
By removing tipping from the Linkery, we aligned ourselves with every other business model in America. Servers and management could work together toward one goal: giving all of our guests the best possible experience. When we did it well, we all made more money. As you can imagine, it was easy for us to find people who wanted to work in this environment, with clear goals and rewards for succeeding as a team.
Maybe it wouldn’t work in every restaurant, in every city. Maybe the fact that it worked so well for us was due to some unique set of circumstances. Then again, other service industries like health care and law aren’t exactly lining up to adopt tips as their primary method of compensation. So maybe we’re all just being suckered into believing tipping works.
It’s something you can think about, at least, the next time you’re waiting on a refill of iced tea.
Result of various workplace behaviors in normal workplace versus in tipped restaurant:
Disney Shanghai is annoying people with long lines, and the park isn’t even open yet
The biggest unicorn makers in tech, ranked
The remarkable technology of our human eyes cannot be replicated
North Korea’s labor export program qualifies as human trafficking
you and what army?
An Arab force to solve Arab problems? Don’t believe a word of it
Amazon has quietly changed the way it pays tax in Europe
Of miles and margins
Mass-market electric cars will go 200 miles, but are still a long way from being profitable
From subway stations to frozen lakes—how the world practices yoga
This is how Coursera competes against Google and Facebook for the best talent
In pictures: India becomes a deadly oven
Africa’s biggest economy is shutting down for lack of fuel
The French are invading the American cable industry
Students cheat for good grades. Why not make the classroom about learning and not testing?
The world’s best airport has a horticulture team, a butterfly garden, and 500,000 plants
The doctor who planned the perfect suicide—until he learned to talk about it
ROADS NOT TAKEN
Portland, Oregon, is the alternative commuter’s paradise
What learning cursive really taught me
A BEAUTIFUL MIND
Princeton mathematician John Nash and his wife, Alicia, are killed in a car accident
clearing death row
This man came from Rome to show Americans why the death penalty is wrong
Follow the leader
Why you should care who’s in line to run Africa’s development bank
bad habits die hard
The five rude emails you send every day—and how to stop
not safe for work
Watch: Conan O’Brien gives his staff performance reviews
The new normal
“Game of Thrones” isn’t the only TV show that uses gratuitous rape to advance female plot lines
Nigeria’s Buhari must start his presidency facing crippling fuel scarcity and power cuts