Skip to navigationSkip to content

Britain’s Brexit immigration plan could devastate the most important part of its economy

British flag.
Reuters/Clodagh Kilcoyne
The economy is going to get burned.
By Lianna Brinded
Published Last updated This article is more than 2 years old.

Britain’s economy could be in for a seismic shock.

The government is planning to stop EU citizens from being able to live and work in the UK without visa requirements in March 2019, when Brexit is scheduled to finally happen. While it is not a certainty—after all, negotiations with the EU are underway and subject to change over the next 18 months—the plan could be especially devastating for the services sector.

The services sector, everything from retail to banking, is the lifeblood of Britain’s economy, accounting for around 80% of GDP. The problem with stopping the freedom of movement for EU citizens is that EU migrants account for a large share of jobs.

The services sector relies on the lower-skilled workers from the EU who take up jobs that Britons don’t want. The Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR) found that some industries filled around a third of their jobs with workers from the EU.

Packers, bottlers, canners and fillers
41.6 %
Food, drink, and tobacco processors
Weighers, graders, and sorters
Vehicle valeters and cleaners
Cleaning and housekeeping
Launderers, dry cleaners, and pressers
Industrial cleaning
Fork-lift truck drivers
Other elementary services
Routine inspectors and testers

Even in the National Health Service (NHS), EU migrants account for 10% of doctors and 4% of nurses. IPPR said the NHS would “collapse” without EU migrants.

The UK government has not presented any concrete plans on how EU citizens will apply for residency or work in post-Brexit Britain. The government is working on a year-long study into migration. Whatever the country’s policymakers decide on won’t be known until six months before Brexit happens.

But if EU citizens had to fit the criteria of those applying to live and work in Britain from outside the EU, the salary and skills requirements mean most would not be successful in their applications. Currently, Britain’s government requires migrants seeking “Tier 2” visas for skilled workers to fill graduate-level roles and earn at least £30,000 ($39,600) a year. (The requirements for people under 26 or migrants switching from student visas are a bit less strict.)

So while bankers might be okay—that is, if banks haven’t moved jobs away from London—baristas won’t be. In fact, a study by Oxford University’s Migration Observatory last year found that around three-quarters of EU migrants in Britain would fail this test (paywall).

It looks like EU citizens are starting to give up anyway. Annual net migration was 248,000 in 2016, down from 332,000 the year before, mostly due to a drop in migration from elsewhere in the EU.

📬 Kick off each morning with coffee and the Daily Brief (BYO coffee).

By providing your email, you agree to the Quartz Privacy Policy.