Skip to navigationSkip to content

If China has a real-estate glut, why is Beijing more expensive than Manhattan?

General view of the plot of Xu Jia Hui Center bought by Hong Kong property developer Sun Hung Kai Properties Ltd. in Shanghai, China, 5 September 2013. Hong Kong property giant Sun Hung Kai Properties Ltd. paid one of the highest prices ever for a piece in land in China, snapping up a downtown Shanghai site for a total of 21.77 billion yuan (US$3.57 billion) Thursday (5 September 2013). Hong Kongs largest developer by market value won the right to develop the commercial site at an auction Thursday, the company said. Sun Hung Kais bid for the land in the citys Xujiahui district was 24.2% higher than the starting price of 17.53 billion yuan. It was higher than a competing bid submitted by rival Wharf (Holdings) Ltd., local media Shanghai Evening Post reported. This project, currently named Xu Jia Hui Center is zoned for office, retail and hotel use, and has a total gross floor area above ground of 584,203.6 square meters. This translates into a cost of 37,264 yuan a square meter. Sun Hung Kai, which has recently opened an office and shopping center complex in the city called Shanghai ICC along Huaihai Road, also built the Shanghai IFC, another mixed-use project that includes office, retail and the Ritz Carlton hotel in Pudongs Lujiazui district.(Imaginechina via AP Images
Imaginechina via AP Images
This puppy’s worth $3.6 billion.
  • Gwynn Guilford
By Gwynn Guilford


BeijingPublished Last updated This article is more than 2 years old.

Chinese local governments hit the jackpot this week. In Beijing, Shanghai, Hangzhou and Suzhou, land parcels sold for record prices, crowning a slew of new “land kings,” as Chinese slang refers to record-setting plots. Here’s a roundup of the highlights:

Does this mean supply is scarce?

These prices imply that China is running out of land supply in major cities, though it’s difficult to tell how much supply is in the market because of scarce data. While land prices have soared, the actual plots are getting smaller. In August, developers bought 24.9 million sq m of land in China’s 10 biggest cities; though the area sold was down 0.8% from a year earlier, the value per square meter jumped 151%. And that’s even though major cities have tightened restrictions on home-buying to deter speculators.

That would also explain why housing prices in big cities continue to soar. Average prices in the top 100 cities rose for the 15th straight month in August.

(Indexed to 2010 prices.)

Actually, it could mean the opposite

But price rises could be due more to speculation than to a dearth of supply. Especially in big cities, apartments are often seen as investment vehicles more than as homesteads. For instance, even though swanky high-rises are getting more expensive in Beijing, their sales in smaller cities are flagging, suggesting that genuine demand is weak. As Bank of America-Merrill Lynch’s China strategy team noted in March, “China is building too many housing units too fast.” Per capita housing stock, they note, hit 35 sq m in 2011, and is rising by 1.2 sq m a year, putting China in the same league as many wealthy countries:

BofA Merrill Lynch

That rate picked up in 2012, even as the housing market slumped that year. Moreover, when you calculate per-capita housing stock not by the general population but by the number of people who hold a hukou, or residence permit, housing completed in 2012 leapt in Beijing, Shanghai and Tianjin, as well as in Liaoning province:

Yichuan Wang based on National Bureau of Statistics data

The impact on local governments

As in any country, China’s real-estate market is actually a multitude of smaller markets, each of which has different supply-demand dynamics. Rigid demand in mega-cities like Beijing and Shanghai can probably absorb any excess supply. But oversupply is already hitting smaller cities, and as demand flags, prices have started to fall (link in Chinese). If that fall becomes severe enough to make developers run short of cash, they may discount their inventories in larger cities and cause prices to suffer there too.

If house values fall that could be bad news for China’s financial system, because people frequently use property as collateral. But the greatest impact will be on local governments, many of which now have colossal debt burdens as a result of stimulus spending. Largely unable to issue their own debt because of central government restrictions, local governments depend on selling land (both government-owned plots and occupied plots seized by force) for revenue. In 2011, those sales accounted for more than 60% of local government revenue. As the Heritage Foundation’s Derek Scissors points out, at 5.9 trillion yuan, land sale revenue in 2010 and 2011 alone exceeded the 5.3 trillion yuan total from 1999 to 2008. ”This rate of increase cannot possibly last,” writes Scissors.

Yichuan Wang contributed data analysis and map illustration.

📬 Kick off each morning with coffee and the Daily Brief (BYO coffee).

By providing your email, you agree to the Quartz Privacy Policy.