Skip to navigationSkip to content
FALSE HOPES

Photos: The secret world of maids in New York’s richest neighborhoods

Xyza Cruz Bacani
Daisy Benin Santon is a single mother who works as a nanny on the Upper East Side. New York, June 27, 2015
Published This article is more than 2 years old.

Xyza Cruz Bacani was a domestic worker for nearly ten years, before the world recognized her as photographer. Now, in an ongoing project to document human trafficking and overseas workers, the 29-year-old prodigy reveals the dark reality of female domestic workers in the United States.

Shot with the help of the Damayan Migrant Workers Association, a non-profit for Filipino domestic workers’ rights in New York and New Jersey, Xyza’s photos portray women who were professionals in the Philippines, before emigrating to become nannies and housekeepers in the Upper East Side and other wealthy areas of New York City.

“These women have been away from their families for a long time,” Xyza tells Quartz. “All they wanted was to have a better life for their families and the toll of family separation really hits them.”

Xyza Cruz Bacani
Domestic worker Daisy skyping with her children. She has three daughters back in the Philippines, and has not seen her children for 7 years. Queens, NYC. July 21, 2015

Daisy Benin is one of Xyza’s subjects. “Daisy is doing everything for her children,” says Xyza. “She talks to them everyday via Skype, assists on their homework. She tries to be a mom even though she is millions of miles away.”

An estimated 23% of domestic workers in the United States are paid below the state minimum wage, according to advocacy group National Domestic Workers Alliance. Nearly all domestic workers in the US are women, and about half are immigrants. Xyza explains that many of the women she photographed and followed expressed disappointment that the United States they encountered was not what they were expecting:

Many Filipinos want to move to the US, but what they see on ads and television is not the reality of life of migrants. During the time I spent with these women, we had many intimate conversations. They told me that the advertising they saw at home created a false hope that once you’re in America, you can earn lots of money and build a better life.

While some of Xyza’s subjects have been forced into labor or abandoned by traffickers, she says she hopes her photos will undo stereotypes of victimhood for domestic workers, and notes that there is no one way for a domestic worker to look or act. ”When I show these images to other people, they make comments like, ‘How can victims be using computers?!'” she laughs.

Xyza Cruz Bacani
Daisy works as a domestic worker in the Upper East Side, New York. July 1,2015.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Cherry is on her way to a job interview after being unemployed for almost a year due to her injuries. Brooklyn, NYC. July 22, 2015.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Cherry Ann wearing her hijab. She converted to Islam after being married for a year to a Muslim man from Bangladesh. Brooklyn, NYC. June 29, 2015.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Cherry Ann in Brooklyn, NYC. June 29, 2015.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Cherry preparing breakfast for her husband, who works as an accountant. Brooklyn, NYC. June 29, 2015.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Daisy doing her employers’ laundry, New York, June 27, 2015.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Daisy inside her employers’ home.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Daisy talking to one of her daughters in the Philippines.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Daisy packing a box to send home to her kids in the Philippines. Queens, NY. July 6,2015.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Cherry fixing her hijab at Daisy’s apartment in Queens. July 6, 2015.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Daisy lives in a tiny bedroom in Queens. July 02,2015
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Domestic worker Judith inside her home in Brooklyn. July 25, 2015.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Judith preparing dinner for her children, who have come to join her. July 25, 2015.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Judith’s home is full of mementos.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Judith at home.
Xyza Cruz Bacani
Judith and her children sleep together in one room during the summer to save electricity on air conditioning. July 30, 2015.

📬 Kick off each morning with coffee and the Daily Brief (BYO coffee).

By providing your email, you agree to the Quartz Privacy Policy.