Skip to navigationSkip to content
HEALTH CARES

Stressful healthcare systems have left doctors suffering with depression and stress without help

doctors
Reuters/Punit Paranjpe
The diagnosis isn’t good.
  • Jamie Hacker Hughes
By Jamie Hacker Hughes

Professor, Anglia Ruskin University

This article is more than 2 years old.

A new study from Cardiff University has revealed that nearly 60% of doctors have experienced mental illness and psychological problems at various stages in their careers. That is bad enough in itself, but what is much worse is that very few of the 2000 surveyed said that they had sought help.

A number of health professionals and professionals from other industries have been studied in recent years and many, not unsurprisingly, also show high levels of stress. Sadly, however, it seems that this failure to seek help is not a phenomenon that is confined purely to the medical profession.

Findings from the British Psychological Society and New Savoy, for example—reporting on their 2015 staff well-being survey—showed that nearly half of psychological professionals report being depressed, along with admitting feelings of being a failure.

Work again was a culprit, with 70% of those who responded saying that they were finding their jobs stressful. For both medical doctors and psychological doctors, therefore, the current climate is not, sadly, a healthy one. Workers on the front line of care are becoming governed more and more by contracts and targets rather than by the imperative of caring for people. The threat of cuts, often presented as efficiency savings, and the imposition of contracts on junior doctors are just two of many current examples.

Risk and resolution

Across the caring professions—medical, psychological, nursing, and those allied to medicine and caring—there is, overall, a picture of worrying levels of depression and stress leading to low morale and burnout.

Burnout is something experienced by people who have been working on the front line of human services in a context where they are caring for, and committed to providing services to, others. Its features are a combination of high levels of depersonalization—where a person no longer sees themselves or others as valuable—and emotional exhaustion together with low levels of feelings of personal accomplishment. This is exactly what we are seeing reported here in the Cardiff study.

The Cardiff study found that the likelihood of doctors reporting mental health problems differed between different stages of their careers: Young doctors and trainees were least likely to disclose any problems. Female doctors were found to be particularly at risk of burnout, as were GPs and trainee and junior doctors.

Almost certainly, the reason why is stigma. People throughout society—particularly frontline professionals—are afraid of disclosing that they are having problems because they fear the repercussions and possible effects that disclosure may have on their careers.

This was also recently demonstrated in a wider paper by Sarah Clements of Kings College London who, with colleague Graham Thornicroft, carried out a meta analysis of 144 studies involving more than 90,000 people. Their resulting global report showed that although one in four people—both inside and outside the healthcare profession—in Europe and the USA have a mental health problem, as many as 75% of people do not receive treatment.

What—if anything—can be done about this situation? Do we really want to consult with professionals who are less able to confront their own difficulties than we are? How can we help them confront their own issues to help others in society overcome the stigma?

There have been moves toward a more open mental health culture within the health professions, with some senior members of staff sharing their experiences. Retired GP Chris Manning, for example, has been greatly involved in the promotion of doctors’ psychological health and self-care after experiencing depression and burnout.

Clare Gerarda, former chair of the Council of the Royal College of General Practitioners, has also been a long-time advocate for doctors’ health and is the medical director of the Practitioner Health Program—a free and confidential NHS service for doctors and dentists who are experiencing psychological or physical health concerns. Additionally, Dr. Gerarda established the Founders Group and Founders Network, a coalition working together to promote psychologically healthy environments within the NHS.

A new charter on psychological staff wellbeing and resilience was also launched recently by the British Psychological Society and New Savoy. Building on this, a collaborative learning network of employers in health and social care has been established and will have its first meeting on Jun. 21 in order to begin working together to establish and maintain psychologically healthy working environments.

Fundamentally, though, there has to be a change in culture. People need to be able to speak freely about their feelings of stress and psychological needs—and be supported to seek help. I have tried, personally, to model this as the president of the British Psychological Society over this past year and have talked openly about my own experiences of burnout, stress, depression, and bipolar disorder while working as a clinical psychologist.

It is my belief that this culture change could begin to be enabled for doctors—both medical and psychological—nurses, allied health professionals, and all in the caring professions too, if managers begin to talk openly about their own psychological health.

To do so is a sign of strength and humility.

This post originally appeared at The Conversation.

📬 Kick off each morning with coffee and the Daily Brief (BYO coffee).

By providing your email, you agree to the Quartz Privacy Policy.