Skip to navigationSkip to content
PLASTIC ARTS

The best rewards credit card isn’t a Chase Sapphire Reserve, after all

AP Photo/Elise Amendola
Which one loves you back?
This article is more than 2 years old.

People obsessed with credit card rewards have turned the business mantra “you have to spend money to make money” into a rigorous daily practice.

But how much are they really getting back for all those avocado toasts and other purchases? A new study by personal finance website WalletHub found a sleek, premium rewards card isn’t always the best bet for consumers. The site analyzed credit card issuers’ rewards programs and 79 credit cards to determine how easily cardholders could earn, redeem, hold onto points, and how transparent the banks were about their policies. The study left out co-branded cards such as those that are tied to an airline.

The famed Chase Sapphire Reserve, a favorite of globetrotting millennials who pay $450 a year for the privilege of big travel rewards, didn’t edge out its lower-cost competitors. Consumers had lined up in such numbers for the Chase Sapphire Reserve card that the issuing bank had to scale back perks to cardholders.

WalletHub gave the Sapphire Reserve’s cheaper cousin, the $95-a-year Chase Sapphire Preferred, a top score, followed by the zero-fee Venture Rewards from Capital One. The website found how much in rewards customers would get over two years, based on annual spending of $28,523, stripping out fees for each issuer’s top-rated card. Globetrotters rejoice. Redeeming points for travel offered the best value, compared with merchandise, the study said.

Here’s how the the cards stack up:

IssuerCardtwo-year rewards value
BarclaycardBarclaycard Arrival Plus World Elite Mastercard$1,634
DiscoverDiscover it$1,559
US BankAltitude Reserve Visa Infinite Card$1,527
Alliant Credit UnionAlliant CU Visa Platinum Awards Card$1,510
Capital OneVenture Rewards$1,482
ChaseChase Sapphire Preferred$1,338
CitiCiti Thank You Premiere Card$1,311
Bank of AmericaBankAmericard Travel Rewards$1,177
Pentagon Federal Credit UnionPenFed Platinum Rewards Visa Signature Credit Card$1,107
Navy Federal Credit UnionCash Rewards Credit Card$1,056
PNC BankPNC Premier Traveler Visa Signature Credit Card$1,056
American ExpressBlue Cash Preferred Card from American Express$1,033
First National BankFirst National Bank American Express® Card$956

📬 Kick off each morning with coffee and the Daily Brief (BYO coffee).

By providing your email, you agree to the Quartz Privacy Policy.