China’s wealthiest families score $720 billion in undeclared “gray income”

It takes grey income to buy a gold-plated Infiniti G37.
It takes grey income to buy a gold-plated Infiniti G37.
Image: Reuters/China Daily
We may earn a commission from links on this page.

The undeclared “gray” income earned by China’s richest families has reached staggering levels, and is contributing to massive income inequality that is far worse than official statistics, according to research by the state-backed China Society of Economic Reform.

CSER researcher Wang Xiaolu, writing in Caixin magazine, said gray income reached 6.2 trillion renminbi (about $1 trillion) in 2011, or about 12% of GDP, based on a survey of 5,344 families in urban areas that was completed in 2012.

That means the richest 10% of urban Chinese families make almost 21 times more than the poorest 10%, versus official statistics from the National Bureau of Statistics that place the rich-to-poor income ratio at only 8.6. The Gini index for China’s urban households—which measures income distribution on a scale of 0 to 1, where the higher values mean more inequality—was 0.496 according to the CSER data, versus the NBS figure of 0.324. A Gini score over 0.4 is correlated with social instability.

“The richer the household, the more likely it receives shadow income,” Wang noted.

Even some Chinese officials admit that income inequality has been understated, because families often lie on household surveys, and China lacks a comprehensive tax record system to check those results. The government has resisted calls for officials to disclose their assets, and entrepreneurs are similarly cagey.

The upside is that families outside of that top 20% are getting a little more of that pie. The neweset figures show 72% percent of gray income went to the wealthiest 20% of families, compared with 81.3% in 2010. The downside is that this could mean corruption is spreading.

“This tells us that invisible income oozed out from the rich to cover more medium to high-income households, possibly a result of expanded corruption and weak rule of law,” Wang wrote. “The high gray income is linked to the loose credit handed out between 2009 and 2010, as well as the rapid increase of government investment during the same period. When administrative power lacks proper checks, the government intervenes in resource allocation and state money can easily be channeled out into private pockets.”