“It’s this wide berth for interpretation with less clear mechanisms for oversight and restraint that’s most parallel” with Hong Kong’s national security law, said Chong Ja Ian, a Singapore-based political scientist.

In a statement, the Singaporean government has said that its residents and citizens “have the right to discuss politics,” and assured foreign media that critical reportage would be protected. But as in Hong Kong, whose government has also assured citizens and businesses that no “legitimate rights and freedoms” have been curtailed, none of those guarantees are written in law.

“Like with the national security law, there have been many assurances given to businesses in Singapore, but it’s not clear when the authorities can change their minds,” said Chong.

“Moving away from global openness”

Certainly, Singapore has legitimate concerns about foreign interference. A high-profile case of a Singaporean who was caught spying for China in the US, for example, rekindled fears that foreign countries were exploiting Singapore’s openness and strategic location to gather intelligence and recruit spies. And in 2017, Singapore expelled a pro-Beijing academic for acting as a foreign agent.

By contrast, said Chong, examples of foreign interference in Hong Kong pointed to by authorities there have been “quite weak.” Indeed, just this week, Hong Kong government officials and a state-owned propaganda outlet have insinuated or outright accused the city’s largest journalist union of foreign collusion, suggesting it has received foreign money and is in cahoots with foreign outlets like the BBC to “smear” China with negative coverage.

The fact that Asia’s two premier global financial hubs are now separately placing restrictions on international ties and exchanges perhaps hints at a new era in which globalization and the free flow of information are now regarded with more wariness and skepticism.

“I guess, in some ways, this is reflective of a world that’s moving away from the global openness, deregulation… that we’ve been used to over the past 30 years,” said Chong.

📬 Sign up for the Daily Brief

Our free, fast, and fun briefing on the global economy, delivered every weekday morning.