To be more productive, get scientific about your playlist selections

In the zone.
In the zone.
Image: Reuters / Carlos Barria
We may earn a commission from links on this page.

There you go again: browser open in front of you, the hum of your office in the background, your to-do list sprawled out on your screen and waiting to be tackled.

And you just don’t feel like doing anything.

Faced with this serious lack of motivation, you head to Google to see what advice other similarly lost souls have to offer up. You try working offline when possible. You try Pomodoro Technique timers. You take that walk around the block the internet keeps suggesting. Nothing.

And then you open Spotify, and the music numbs your brain just enough that you’re able to focus on that one boring task you have knock out each morning (looking at you, email).

And now you got something done. And now you’re in the zone. When nothing else seems to get us motivated, music does. In terms of work specifically, why does listening to music help us focus?

The answer depends on quite a few factors.

Music, your brain, and emotions

Studies about how music affects our brains and emotions have been ongoing since the the 1950s, when physicians began to notice the benefits of music therapy in European and US hospital patients. However, humans have been using music to communicate thoughts and feelings to one another for centuries.

Today, research suggests that music can help relieve negative emotions like stress, anxiety, and depression. It can even decrease instances of confusion and delirium in elderly medical patients recovering from surgery. Furthermore, research says that listening to happy or sad music can make us perceive others as being happy or sad, respectively. All of these findings make it clear that, for better or worse, music’s impact on our emotions is very real.

In terms of how music affects the brain, we can turn to a specific niche of research called neuromusicology, which explores how our nervous systems react to music. Basically, music enters the inner ear and engages many different areas of our brains, some of which are used for other cognitive functions, as well. (If you want to know the specifics of this detailed process, Dawn Kent goes into detail about it in her senior thesis for Liberty University.)

Somewhat surprisingly, the number of brain areas activated by music varies from person to person, depending on your musical training and your personal experiences with music. Therefore, how music impacts your ability to concentrate or feel a certain emotion can be expected to vary from person to person, too.

However, there are some general brain and mood patterns that modern music research reveals, and these can help us decide what kinds of music to listen to at work.

How music affects your brain and mood at work

For the most part, research suggests that listening to music can improve our productivity, creativity, and happiness in terms of work-related tasks.

However, there are stipulations to these benefits. For example, studies seem to agree that listening to music with lyrics is distracting for most people. Therefore, it’s often recommended that we avoid listening to music featuring lyrics when working on tasks that require intense focus or the learning of new information.

In contrast, listening to music with lyrics may actually help people working on repetitive or mundane tasks, perhaps because the distracting nature of lyrical music can provide a kind of relief from the monotony of boring work.

For a greater understanding of how music affects work, here are just a few of the many studies conducted on workplace productivity and music in recent years:

In 1972, a study published in Applied Ergonomics suggested that people doing repetitive tasks worked more efficiently when background music was played. In 1994, The Journal of the American Medical Association published a study showing that surgeon accuracy and efficiency improved when surgeons worked with music playing. Music selected by the participants had the best results and, even when working with music selected by researchers, the surgeons performed better than those who worked with no music at all.

A 1999 study in the journal of Neuroscience and behavioral physiology showed that playing classical or rock music allowed study participants to identify numbers more quickly and accurately. In 2005, research from the journal of Psychology of Music showed that software developers experienced more positive moods, better quality of work and improved efficiency when listening to music. The study also notes a learning curve for participants using music to alter their moods.

These examples are merely a snapshot of the research that has been conducted on music’s affects on employees, but we can already start to see the benefits music has on work.

Ambient noise may also help

To some extent, one can argue that music is a form of ambient noise. Some musical genres, especially, ask us to consider this comparison: stomp music, industrial music or, as the name suggests, ambient music all incorporate elements of traditionally non-musical sounds with a musical component or structure.

Research suggests that ambient noise, or ambient music as we may prefer to think about it here, could be the best kind of music for work productivity.

A 2006 study from the journal of Ergonomics found continuous noise to be the least annoying background noise, while distinguishable speech was “the most disturbing, most disadvantageous and least pleasant environment” for participants. The study also included a “masked speech” variable, which proved to be the most effective means of arousing participants’ mental states, while (somewhat surprisingly) continuous noise was the least effective.

In 2012, The Journal of Consumer Research published a study investigating the effects of ambient noise on creativity. The study suggested that creative processes improved when participants listened to ambient noise at a moderate volume — about 70 decibels, approximately the volume of a vacuum cleaner. The study also found that creativity suffered in the presence of high-volume ambient noise — about 85 decibels, slightly louder than a garbage disposal.

Additionally, research in 2015 from the The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America found that using natural sounds like a flowing stream was an effective way to improve employees’ productivity and moods in the workplace.

Considering the studies above, it seems that ambient music has the potential to improve our moods and productivity much like other forms of music. However, for music to really improve your productivity at work, you’ll likely need to alternate between periods of no music and periods of different kinds of music.

We can recall that, when learning new information, music without lyrics is preferable to lyrical music. However, if we complete this task at work and need to switch to a more repetitive, well-known task, we may benefit emotionally and productively from listening to music with lyrics. And, depending on the complexity of the task, we’ll likely encounter instances throughout the day when we need to ditch our headphones altogether and simply focus on what’s in front of us.

That said, finding the right kind of music can be challenging at times. This is part of the learning curve mentioned in the Psychology of Music research above. Clicking around to find the right artist can certainly detract from workplace productivity but, once you know what works for you, music can become a tool for near-instant concentration.

Need a place to start? Below are some music suggestions for your work day.

11 Artists To Listen To At Work

Keeping the ever-changing needs of most daily schedules in mind, I’ve picked out a few artists that focus on lyrics and others that are more ambient. Some are more upbeat while others are mellow.

All are available for free on YouTube, Spotify or SoundCloud.

1. Akiko Kiyama

Lyrics: Rare
Genres: Electronic, Industrial
Links: SpotifySoundCloudYouTubeWebsite

2. Pixl

Lyrics: Sometimes
Genres: Electronic, Dubstep
Links: SpotifySoundCloudYouTubeWebsite

3. Bassnectar

Lyrics: Often
Genres: Dubstep, Electronic
Links: SpotifySoundCloudYouTubeWebsite

4. Balmorhea

Lyrics: Sometimes
Genres: Classical, Post-rock, Pop
Links: SpotifySoundCloudYouTubeWebsite

5. The Echelon Effect

Lyrics: Rare
Genres: Ambient, Soundscape, Post-rock
Links: SpotifySoundCloudYouTubeWebsite

6. Wynton Marsalis

Lyrics: Rare
Genres: Jazz, Classical, Orchestral
Links: SpotifySoundCloudYouTubeWebsite

7. Wess Meets West

Lyrics: Rare
Genres: Soundscape, Post-rock, Electronic
Links: SpotifySoundCloudYouTubeWebsite

8. DeVotchKa

Lyrics: Often
Genres: Indie folk, Indie rock
Links: SpotifySoundCloudYouTubeWebsite

9. Color Theory

Lyrics: Often
Genres: Synthpop, Electronic
Links: SpotifySoundCloudYouTube | Website

10. Crystal Castles

Lyrics: Sometimes
Genres: Electronic, Experimental, Noise
Links: SpotifySoundCloudYouTube | Website

11. Andhim

Lyrics: Sometimes
Genres: House, Electronic
Links: SpotifySoundCloudYouTube | Website

Get to know what artists help you knock out specific kinds of work, and you’ll find yourself in a better mood, and better able to focus.

This post originally appeared at The Mission.